MAINE STATE POLICE COVER-UP MIKE COCHRAN
MURDER
On Feb. 21, 2022,
A NEWS CENTER in Maine made a public request for information
on Mike's murder on behalf of the Maine State Police
Below is the NEWS CENTER'S public
request that says the police are pushing for answers to help solve the 41-year-old case
Police seek justice for unsolved death of Dedham man
"Michael Cochran, 24, was found among the rubble of a burned-out
cabin in Dedham on Feb. 24, 1981. Police are
pushing for answers to help solve the 41-[44] year-old cold
case killing of Michael Cochran of Dedham. In a Facebook post, Maine
State Police detectives said the 24-year-old man’s body was
discovered among the rubble of a burned-out cabin in Dedham on
Feb. 24, 1981. Police said they believe the cabin was burned on Feb.
18, 1981. Police ruled his death a
homicide, and the case has remained unsolved. Police are asking
anyone with information about Cochran’s murder to call the Maine State Police Major Crimes Unit at 207-973-3750."
___________________________________________________________________________
|
I am Mike Cochran's mother. I am 90 years
old. In
1981 when Mike was murdered I was 44. I have spent half
my life trying to get justice for Mike. I was first told Mike's
death was an accident. I spent years trying to find out what
happened the night he was murdered while begging the Maine State Police
for help, to no avail. There has been no justice for Mike and I
have been told by the Attorney General's Office that there won't be any because the police
bungled
Mike's case. I would like help to tell what I
uncovered during my many years of fighting for
justice for my son, Mike.
NEWS CENTER MAINE
reports that
"the police said
they believe
the cabin burned on Feb. 18, 1981." And also report that "the Police are
asking anyone with information about Cochran’s murder" to
contact them. I will give them some information concerning
Mike's murder and give them proof that he was murdered on
Feb. 18, 1981.
But first I want to say that I received a letter from Deputy Attorney General William
"Bill" Stokes,written on Sept. 5, 2006 (twenty years
ago) telling me that Mike's murder could not be
prosecuted and why. "Detective Coleman [an honest detective assigned Mike's murder case in 2001,
20 years after Mike's death.] has done
outstanding work on this case but there remains
tremendous
difficulties with prosecuting this case particularly in view of
the fact that the ‘homicide scene’ was not treated as such until a significant period of
time after your son’s death, potentially jeopardizing important
evidence in the meantime." Reporter Eric Russell in his Dec. 3, 2017 article
wrote "Twenty-five-years after Mike's murder
the
state's top homicide
prosecutor admitted that Maine State Police had bungled Mike's murder
investigation from the beginning."
Now, the Maine State Police are "asking anyone with
information about Mike's murder to call" them. What would
they do with the information since the Maine Attorney General's
Office has said that there are
tremendous
difficulties with prosecuting this case?
Twenty years now since AG Stoke wrote his letter, verifies, I think
what he told me, tremendous difficulties with prosecuting this
case.
February 18, 1981:
The cottage where Mike was staying was set on fire on Feb. 18, 1981
at 3:30 am in the morning. Paul Pollard was
the only person in the cottage with Mike and when the fire chief
arrived
on the arson scene he saw Paul Pollard fleeing into the woods. When Det. Shuman arrived
on the murder scene he said there was no need for the
crime lab to respond.
February 24. 1981 The fire
inspector was called but was immediately called away from his
jurisdiction and sent to a Bangor fire. He didn't return until six days later, Feb.
24. While he and his assistant, Maine State Police Allan
Jamison, were digging through the 6 day old pile of fire rubble they discovered
Mike's body. Jamison made a call to the authrities and other fire personnel arrived to help and they took notes.
Note #1
says "Norm [Dedham Fire Chief Norman Herrin] saw male subject
running in woods wiping hands. -Tracks looked like went to main
road where subjuct was picked up."
Note #2
says Lionel Cormier and Percy Sargent arrived in "green car,
beat up, no front plate" - at the bottom note it says
"homicide." "I
believe thiese notes disputes Deputy AG Stokes information that "the
'homicide scene' was not treated as such until a significant
period of time after your son's death."
states "1200 hr - 2-24-81 - roped off
- Fire scene awaiting D.A. and 952 (CID III) to follow up investigation relative to this being a
homicide."
Forty-three-year veteran Fire Inspector Wilbur Ricker
later testified
that he had many years of experience in finding burned bodies in
fires And from his experience he knew that "something was added
to the body to cause that amount of damage, more than the
building."
The Maine State Police had a "Crime Laboratory [that]
served Maine since 1926. "Our services are offered to all law
enforcement agencies operating within the borders of Maine. The
Crime Laboratory employs some of the most state-of-the-art
equipment and instrumentation available to the scientific
community?"
Why was Shuman's
order of "no need for the crime lab to respond allowed to stand
when Maine had "some of the most state-of-the-art equipment
to test the tissues for gasoline? A Feb. 27, 1981
lab
report states that "the blood contained a carbon
monoxide level of 46% of saturation." But no test was done for
gasoline in the tissue to verify Ricker's claim of something
added to the body.
February 25, 1981 The day after Mike was found Shuman visited Mike's father at
his work requesting dental records. He never came back. MSP Det.
Shuman and Bangor Police Det. Roger Bryce visited Mike's
girlfriend, Linda Gray, immediately upon leaving the arson/murder
scene the day Mike was found, Feb. 24, and told her
that men from Massachusetts went to the cottage, knocked Mike
unconsious, and set the cottage on fire. That evening Linda
called my sister and told her what the police had told her. Shuman never mentioned this to
Mike's father when he visited him at work the next morning
or ever visited our home to tell us anything. Neither Linda nor Shuman
ever admitted this information, but the Maine State Police told
this to
Hartford fire
insurance agent Michael MeagherAn
autopsy was also done on the
25th by Deputy Chief Ronald Roy preformed an autopsy at 10:40 am.
"Upper and lower jaws removed for further identification."
February 26, 1981 We didn't know that on February 26, 1981 a medical examiner signed a
permit
stating
"no further examination or judicial inquiry concerning this
death is necessary. Permission is hereby granted to cremate the
dead body of the person named hereon." Could this also
have helped jeopardize important evidence, as Deputy Bill Stokes
said in his letter? We didn't know until 1986 that Deputy ME Ronald
Roy stated in his
autopsy report that a scar
was found on Mike's chest and that it was part of the
identification of Mike. Chief Medical Examiner Dr. Henry Ryan also referred to the scar in a
letter
I received from him in
1981 saying the scar was "very strong corroborating evidence
for identification." Dr. Ryan
wrote AG LaRochelle in 1988
in reference to a letter I wrote Ryan and again referred to the scar
as part of their identification of Mike.
Mike's scar was on his neck from an biopsy and January 1977
hospital records prove this. It
states
“With the patient under general anesthesia the skin of the neck was prepared and suitable drapes were applied. A transverse (cross ways) incision was made just above the suprasternal notch.”
Photo of Mike
showing scar on his neck. While we were being told Mike's death
was an accident
lab reports
state arson-murder. One report reports the victim as William
Cochran. One of Derald's coworkers also worked part-time at a
local funeral home offered to help us. He told Derald that
the body had been identified as Mike (the body hadn’t actually
been
identified at that time, but we
didn’t know it) and that he was informed that the fire was an
accident and Mike just didn’t make it out. Mike was in the wrong
place at the wrong time. We believed
what we were told. Charles Thomas made arrangements to have
Mike's body transported to Clark & Mitchell Funeral Home where
he worked. He suggested a cremation since Mike's body was burned
beyond recognition. We took his advise not knowing Mike was
murdered. Later, I received Mike's death certificate.
It states that Mike was "trapped
in house fire" verifying what we were told. So, we were in the dark when
it was suggested to us that a cremation was best. We didn't know that the tissues or
blood had not been tested for gasoline. We didn't know that
Mike's body had not been identified when his body was returned
to his family. We didn't know that
Mike's jaws had been kept at the medical examiner's office
for "further
dental identification" (returned to Mike's
family 21 years later)
December 1984 Mike's family was not aware that the state had
indicted and arrested three men, Richard Sargent, Roger Johnson
and Bill Myers, for Mike's murder. We
read it in our local newspaper
the next day, December 6, 1984.
Shuman had interviewed some informants before the men were
indicted. The first interview was with informant Sharon Sargent
his only witness. the other
informant was
David Harriman. He discussed the Dolan robberies with both of
them months before he went to Massachusetts to see Paul Pollard.
Two month later, Homicide Detective Shuman's
only
witness met with Richard Sargent's attorney to deny the story she told
the grand jury. She told the attorney that she was afraid of
Det. Shuman, and that Shuman had been leading and suggestive in
his line of questioning, and that she had committed perjury. Three months later, the state's only witness (A drug
addict with a criminal record) withdrew her
grand jury testimony and again accused Det. Shuman (lead detective on Mike's
murder), of giving her
the story
and saying she feared him. Six months later, June 1985, the state was forced to
dismiss
the indictments and the men walked free.
February 1985
*Shuman knew he was losing his arson/murder case without Sharon Sargent. He was very upset especially with Richard's attorneys for causing him to
lose his arson/murder case. Shuman
was now seeking
revenge and determined to get incriminating information on Richard
Sargent according to Attorney Hilary Billing's 1988 letter to
the Maine Bar. (Attorney in Stern's
firm who also represented Richard). In Februarty of 1985, Det.
Shuman and Trooper Ronald Graves traveled nearly 300 miles to
Worcester, Massachusetts to see Paul Pollard. Richard gave
me a
statement
that was not in the state's discovery. It is a statement in
Shuman's words of what he says Paul Pollard (Man seen fleeing
into the woods away from the murder scene when the fire chief
arrived) told him and Graves during their interview of Pollard
at a Worcester Police department. When Shuman and Graves returned to Maine several men
were indicted for 2 armed robberies. Richard Sargent, Percy
Sargent, Lionel Cormier and Paul Pollard years previous carried out the 1st
armed robbery on November 1980. Lionel Cormier, Paul Pollard and
Robert Smith did the 2nd armed robbery on March 1981. But
Pollard was not indicted for either armed robbery regardless of
participating in both robberies while armed and getting
thousands of dollars from the robbeires. He was
given immunity and was the state's witness against the other 3
men. The first trial begain in July of 1986 for Richard Sargent
and August for Cormier and Smith. Testimony of Homicide Detective Shuman (lead detective) on Mike's case:



Pollard's testimony:


Shuman and Pollard testified one year
later that Shuman visited Pollard in Massachusetts to question
him about "the fire." But Pollard wanted to clear his conscience
of 2 armed robberies. The homicide detective agreed to help Pollard clear his conscience and left
"the fire" (Mike's murder) for a cold case. Pollard gave a 6
page statement that is
in Shuman's words of what he says Pollard told them.
Pollard
returned to Maine in July of 1986 to testify for the state
against Richard, Pollard's half-brother, Lionel Cormier and
friend by the name of Robert Smith. Richard's trial was held
first in July and Cormier and Smith's in August. Shuman and
Pollard both testified that Shuman's vistit to see Pollard was
to talk to Pollard about "the fire" (Mike's murder), but
Pollard didn't want to talk about Mike's murder he wanted to
clear his conscious of 2 armed robberies he had participated
in. So Shuman came back to Maine and with his friend District
Attorney Christopher Almy they prosecuted Richard, Cormier and
Smith. Richard was found guilty and was sentenced to 14 years in
prison for the Nov. 1980 robbery and Paul Pollard was given
immunity for both the Nov. 1980 and the March 1981 robberies.
Shuman got vengence and Pollard cleared his conscience.
*****I met the three men when I attended
a trial for Richard Sargent in Bangor. The state was now
prosecuting the men for the crimes Pollard told Shuman he wanted
to clear his conscious of. prosecuting Richard for armed robberies along with Paul
Pollard's half-brother, Lionel Cormier. Pollard also was
involved in the armed robberies but he was the state's only
witness against Richard and Cormier. Det. Shuman testified but committed perjury when he tried to cover-up
Pollard's crimes. I talked with the
men
during breaks in the trial. They told me that Shuman tried to
frame them for Mike's murder. They offered me their
discovery.
Their discovery included many documents and a wealth of
information. Included was Fire Inspector
a href="POLLARD-fire-investigation-2-18--24-1981.html">Wilbur
Ricker and MSP
Allen Jamison's 1981 fire marshal reports;
Det.
Shuman
and Det. Pinkham's
1981 homicide investigation reports with
statements and many other reports, autopsy
(that I was refused), death
certificate, and lab reports. Richard gave me a
statement
that was not in the discovery documents. It is a statement in Shuman's
words of what he says Paul Pollard (Man seen fleeing into the
woods away from the murder scene when the fire chief arrived)
told him. Shuman travelled nearly 300 miles to Massachusetts
on Feb. 12, 1985 to see Pollard. Shuman and Pollard testified
one year later that the visit was to question Pollard about "the fire"
(Mike's murder). But Pollard wanted to clear his
conscious of 2 armed robberies. The homicide detective agreed to
help Pollard clear his conscience and left "the fire" for
a cold case.
July 1986 Prosecutor DA Christopher Almy
Testimony by Det. Shuman (lead detective) on Mike's murder:


August 1986 Cormier's Defense Attorney
Martha Harris Testimony by Det. Shuman: : 



August 1986 Cormier's Defense Attorney Martha Harris
Testimony by Paul Pollard:


There
was also interviews of the three men when they were arrested and
indicted in 1984 for Mike's murder. None of the people who were with Mike the
night he was murdered were mentioned in 1984, not even Fire
Inspector Wilbur Ricker or
Maine State Police Cpl. Allen Jamison.
The discovery documents answered
many questions I couldn't get answers to for 5 years. And showed
how untruthful Shuman and Pinkham had been with the information
they gave me.
I also attended Lionel Cormier's trial in August. There
were two
witnesses against Cormier, his half-brother Paul Pollard and Robert Smith. Smith was
Pollard's good friend who helped with the second armed robbery.
He was given a reduced sentence to testifying against Cormier.
Pollard again was given complete immunity for his testimony.
I heard Pollard testify that he
had a
.357 pistol on him the morning
he ran from the murder scene and that he had
a
firearm charge against him.
He also said he
fled
the state after Mike's murder. I heard
Pollard's attorney testify that he helped Pollard dispose of
shotguns, rifles and dynamite
taken
during burglaries. Shuman was
allowed to testify to Pollard's credible character but
committed
perjury. One year later, Cormier's attorney
argued
Shuman's perjury before the Maine Supreme Court but the appeal was
denied.
After Cormier's trial was over I started searching for
information on Pollard. I found some serious crimes Paul Pollard had committed
and information on how the crimes were expunged by DA David Cox
and also listened to Det. Shuman
commit perjury to
try cover for Pollard's crimes, which included:
A Forgery
on Feb. 5, 1979. He was
arrested on Feb. 24, 1981,
two years later for the forgery and on the same day Mike's body was found. He paid a $250 fine. Nov. 26, 1980,
he committed an
Armed robbery
and was given immunity. Jan. 23, 1981, he committed
Reckless conduct (firing 5 bullets in to
a family residence as he drove by. one bullet hit 2 feet over a
child's bed). He was
indicted
on March 2. And on March 3, Shuman arrested him (which he denied under
oath) and transported him to Bangor, where he was jailed in the Penobscot County Jail
and segregated from other prisoners. on Oct. 19, 1981, Penobscot
County DA David Cox with help from Assistant Attorney General Pat Perrino, the
indictment was dismissed.
On February 18, 1981, Pollard was the only person in the cottage
with Mike when Mike's death occurred and was seen fleeing into the
woods away from the arson/murder scene by the fire chief when he
arrived. in July of 1986, Shuman
testified
that he had to "talk with the Penobscot County District Attorney "before any type
of bargain was made" for Pollard to be "free from prosecution in
the murder." March 27, 1981, one month after Mike's murder,
Pollard committed another
Armed robbery. He again was
given complete immunity. Pollard testified in August of 1986 that
he had a
Smith &
Wesson .357 gun on him during the armed robberies and that
he had the gun on him when he fled the arson/murder scene.
At Superior Court I found documents concerning
burglaries of rifles, shotguns and dynamite
in a folder for Lionel Cormier (I was told that there was no folder for
Paul Pollard). Pollard had the cache stored
in his apartment in Massachusetts. After Mike's murder the
authorities starting to clean Pollard up. Penobscot County
DA Cox and Pollard's attorney agreed to help. Pollard transported the cache of
guns and dynamite out of Boston, Mass,
across the State of New Hampshire and 178 miles across Maine
before reaching his attorney in Bangor. The cache was loaded
into Pollard's attorney's vehicle and his attorney then transported
them to the Bangor Police Department with approval from
Penobscot County DA David Cox. The Bangor Police carried it all into the Bangor
PD. The dynamite was deteriorating. The police transported the dynamite to the Bangor dump and
blew it up with an ambulance standing by. The report lists Pollard as
an "unnamed
client." No charges were filed.
By 1989 I had accumulating a lot of information especially
information against Paul Pollard. He was with Mike the night he
was murdered and seen fleeing into the woods away from the
murder scene. I borrowed $30,000 against my home to hire an
attorney (Michael Popkin) to file suit against Pollard. The case was filed in US District Court
in Bangor for Intentional Infliction of
Emotional Distress. March 14, 1990,
Pollard's attorney filed for the case to be dismissed of for
summary judgment. March 22, 1990, Popkin responded stating that gas
poured on Mike was the cause of my
Emotional Distress. The case was not dismissed.
March 23, 1990, Deputy Chief Medical
Examiner (DCME) Ronald Roy’s
deposition testimony was taken at my attorney's law
firm. His deposition was transcribed and video
recorded. But
shortly after his deposition he left the United States and
went to Canada leaving us with only his video testimony.
We went to trial on May 11, 1990. It never entered my
mind when I brought suit against Pollard that the Maine State
Police and the Attorney General's Office would get involved in my
lawsuit and continue their cover-up of Paul
Pollard. The Attorney General's Office hired my attorney and on
April 30, 1990, eleven days before trial, my attorney
walked out on me.
And to top it all off Maine
State Police Detectives Shuman (lead detective on Mike's case)and Pinkham wanted to testify for
Pollard.
Attorney Jed Davis (new attorney on the case) submitted a
motion to the
court asking that Shuman and Pinkham not be witnesses for
Pollard. But Shuman was allowed to testify for Paul Pollard and
the short while I was on the stand, I looked down on
the face of Shuman and Pollard sitting together. I don’t have any record of why that happened other than believing the judge must have allowed it.
Needless to say I lost my lawsuit against Paul Pollard. The Bangor Daily News
reported
the one day trial.
After my lawsuit was over, I drove the 80 miles to
August and asked for my file. I was told Attorney Davis was
on vacation and I would have to wait until he returned. I
demanded my file and it was given to me. I carried two large
heavy boxes to my car. When I got home I found letters Popkin had sent
to the court, and to Pollard's attorney.
One letter showed that two weeks after Roy's deposition, and
without consulting me, my attorney sent a letter to Pollard's
attorney saying he was
excising most of Deputy Ronald Roy's testimony: "everything that has to do with the dental
identification or with identification generally." and
"everything that has to do with the identification of the
medical examiner's file." (excise everything that made Roy look incompetent).
And three days later he again wrote Pollard's attorney
saying You will notice that I have excised everything to do
with the "gasoline on the body issue." I will not offer Bill
Ricker's opinion on this issue. I will not offer any expert
testimony to the effect that gasoline was poured on the body.
This was wiping out my Intentional Infliction of Emotional
Distress claim. No wonder I lost my law suit. A new attorney not
familiar with my case and my emotional distress emoved from the
suit along with the lead detective on Mike's case allowed to
testify.
And
three days later he wrote Pollard's attorney saying he was
excising everything about gas on the body issue.
tion testimony,
the part Popkin redacted and
the
jury didn't hear
and in his letter to Pollard's attorney he said he was
excising everything to do with gas on the body." of Roy's testimony that Popkin
chose for the
jury to hear.
All the jury
heard was a video with only a sliver of Dr. Roy’s deposition testimony with Roy
saying there was no trauma to Mike’s body. In
another letter Popkin wrote to Pollard's attorney he said that he was
not going to use Fire Inspector Wilbur Ricker's opinion that gas was poured
on Mike. This was wiping out my Intentional Infliction of
Emotional Distress claim.
One day while talking on the phone with Popkin he said
that he was
not going to use Ricker's opinion that gas was poured on Mike.
I
was very upset (He didn't mention that he was altering Roy's
deposition testimony) and we had a heated argument before we hung
up. I was crying when I called the owner of the firm. He assured
me that it would be included in court testimony, but it wasn't.
I still have the transcribed depositions along with videos of
Fire Inspector Wilbur Ricker, Fire Chief Norman Herrin and
Deputy Chief Medical Examiner Ronald Roy's deposition testimony
that was taken in preparation for trial. Ricker's
deposition disputes
Paul Pollard's
March 3, 1980 and
February 12, 1985
statements of waking and finding the cottage on fire and fleeing
because he was afraid. His testimony also disputes Deputy Chief
Medical Examiner Ronald Roy's description of how injury
occurred as "Trapped
in house fire." Ricker testified the glass in the
door was broken out to allow someone access to the cottage and
that broken glass was under Mike's body. Ricker said
gas was poured on Mike.
Forty-three-year veteran Fire Inspector
Wilbur Ricker found Mike's body on the morning of February
24. He
later
testified
that his many years of experience with finding burned bodies in
fires told him that
"something was added to the body to cause that amount of damage,
more than the building." A Feb. 27, 1981
lab
report states that "the blood contained a carbon monoxide
level of 46% of saturation." The Maine State Police were
notified. | |